SUNDAY NOVEMBER 22 2009
 
 
Please excuse our appearance due to overwhelming traffic. Do visit our mirror site at www2.themalaysianinsider.com
Top News | Malaysia | Business | World | Showbiz | Sports | Features | Opinion | Food | Bahasa | About Us
 
Opinion

How you become a racist ...

NOV 2 — In the past week, newspapers in Sarawak have been covering a story of an Iban-Chinese girl who was denied a place in the matriculation programme because she was deemed a “non-Bumiputera”. This is what the Borneo Post (Oct 29) reported:

“KUCHING: Getting her Sijil Pelajaran Malaysia (SPM) result was the best — and the worst — thing that could happen to Marina Undau.The 18-year-old science stream student of SMK Simanggang scored 9As and 1B in the SPM examination last year. She thought she was on her way to university, especially being a Bumiputera and all, but that was not to be. Born to an Iban father and a Chinese mother, Marina’s life was turned upside down when her application to undergo a university matriculation programme was rejected by the Ministry of Education. The ministry determined that she is not a ‘Bumiputera’...

“Seated between her parents, Undau Liap and Wong Pick Sing, the disappointment in the teenager was obvious. Speaking in Iban, she said: ‘Aku amai enda puas ati nadai olih nyambung sekula ngagai universiti (I’m very sad that I can’t pursue my university education).’ With no chance of entering a university for now, Marina has started Form 6 in her old school.

“Asked what she thought of everything that was happening, she replied: ‘What worries me is that will this happen again when I pass my STPM next year? If I get good results, what’s next?’

“In Sarawak, under the federal constitution, both parents must be ‘native’ in order for the offspring to be classified as a ‘Bumiputera’.”

In case you are curious how they play the blood game, this is the official definition used by the Student Intake Management Division, Higher Learning Department and Higher Education Ministry:

You are a Bumiputera if

• Semenanjung — “Jika salah seorang ibu atau bapa calon adalah seorang Melayu yang beragama Islam/Orang Asli seperti mana yang ditakrifkan dalam Perkara 160(2) Perlembagaan Persekutuan; maka anaknya adalah dianggap seorang Bumiputera.” (If either parent of a candidate is a Malay who is a Muslim/Orang Asli as defined in Article 160 (2) of the Federal Constitution, the child is considered a Bumiputera.)

• Sabah — “Jika bapa calon adalah seorang Melayu yang beragama Islam/Peribumi Sabah seperti yang ditakrifkan dalam Perkara 161A(6)(a) Perlembagaan Persekutuan; maka anaknya adalah dianggap seorang Bumiputera.” (If the father of the candidate is a Malay who is a Muslim/native of Sabah as defined by Article 161A(6)(a) of the Federal Constitution, the child is considered a Bumiputera.)

• Sarawak — “Jika bapa dan ibu adalah seorang Peribumi Sarawak seperti mana yang ditakrifkan dalam Perkara 161A(6)(b) Perlembagaan persekutuan; maka anaknya adalah dianggap seorang Bumiputera.”  (If the father and mother is a native of Sarawak as defined under Article 161A(6)(b) of the Federal Constitution, the child is considered a Bumiputera.)

Since this story broke, many others from mixed, i.e. native-Chinese background, have come forward to tell their appalling stories about not being able to enter matriculation classes and a direct route to a public university.

Just in case you do not know, to enter a public university in Malaysia, you can either do the one-year matriculation programme or the two-year STPM. But there is a catch. The matriculation is only available to Bumiputeras so all the non-Bumiputeras must take the STPM route. It is also common knowledge that matriculation is much easier than STPM and once you get in, you are almost certain to get a university place. Hence, the desperate rush to get into matriculation (see quoted story above).

Oh, before you get any ideas in your head, according to the government, we practice “meritocracy” in the intake of university students! But don’t ask hard questions like why matriculation is restricted or that there is a separate university for Bumiputeras only.

What really bothers me is not the individual sad stories about how children from native-Chinese marriages are denied their Bumiputera rights, but how the media is only reporting from one side. All the stories tell of how their future is damaged since they cannot get into the matriculation programme, and how they are “forced” to go to STPM or Sixth Form.

It is truly shocking that none of the newspaper dare to write the real angle of the story — how about the thousands of poor Chinese students who are denied a place in university because they are completely shut off from the matriculation programme. Are you telling me that there are no poor Chinese or Indians in Sarawak, or that all poor non-Bumiputeras in Sarawak, or for that matter in the whole of Malaysia, happily go into the two-year, tougher STPM and “try their luck” with university admission?

Why do the newspapers only focus on the children of mixed marriages?

Isn’t this exactly why normal people become racist when they see this sort of shenanigans happening right in front of them? How do you explain to your child that she cannot enter university because she was born of the “wrong” race? Education is one of the most basic human rights and here we using higher education to turn an ordinary human being into a racist — all because someone is obsessed with the definition of race. No wonder Sarawak is the model for 1 Malaysia!


Comments (21)
written by Bob, November 03, 2009
Mira, ur comment is worrisome. After 51 years of Barisan Nasional / (Perikatan) with UMNO in power, you say that 90% of the poor will be Malay. Then what u r saying is that the NEP has been a failure.

Although your predictive model might be questionable (at least on the surface the algorithm appears similar to that used by EPU), nevertheless to conclude that 90% will be Malay is an indictment against UMNO and BN.

Very worrisome.
written by Joe, November 03, 2009
We could be racist, but the one who grip the steering wheel of our country must bring us to the right route. Race issue isn't a weapon for them to win the vote. I wonder how Malaysia gonna be when all the crude oil has no more crude oil. God Bless...
written by Durian Besar, November 03, 2009
Great country, lousy government and hopeless policies.
written by change28, November 03, 2009
My sympathy still lies with the Bumiputras.

Day in day out, UMNO/BN leaders keeps telling them they are uncompetitive. Day in day out, UMNO/BN leaders exploit the bumiputras.

The non-bumiputras suffer but in the long term, this toughening the non-bumis undergo means they can face adversities.

As for Najib, he is the most ineffectual leader this country has ever had. This is a PM who has decide that it is more important to look good than to actually do something good.
written by swipenter, November 03, 2009
As long as the Malay/bumiputra rights are placed above human rights we as a counrty will always have official sanctioned racism. Already we are officially divided and segregated into bumi/non bumi, malay bumi/non malay bumi, muslim/non muslim, chinese, indian, malay, dayak, murut, iban and what have you.
The subtle discrimination are legally, legislatively and econonmically done officially. It is now that these "unspeakables" are being openly discussed and people are demanding fairness, equality and justice as citizens of this country and an end to official discrimination.
written by dids, November 03, 2009
It is sad we still have this kind of different race thing. Maybe its because we have different schools for different races. Think about it.
written by Mira, November 03, 2009
Meritocracy is not the see all end all of everything. I was shocked to read comments about a class of 38 Chinese, and no malay. If you thing this is the right path to progression, we will end out with anarchy. Its about achieving a balance. Ever heard the term social inclusion? Siding out kids just because of results create an elitist mentality and that is not right. BTW, even in Singapore, residences and classes have a minority element guaranteed. What is needed is reform - making sure the poor are benefeciaries (and trust me, if you help the poor, 90% of the recipient will be Malay!)
written by Joshua, November 03, 2009
How come a bumiputera right have to be attained by becoming a muslim first. Wasn't bumiputera referring to original people whose ancestory goes back to their original ancestor who lived on this land.

Mahathir 's dad is a mamak. Indian who embraces Islam in order to qualify himself as a malay/bumiputera...Zambry's look like having indian blood in him...how does that qualify him as a bumiputera...in fact quite a major portion of UMNO are malays but not bumiputeras.?
written by sp, November 03, 2009
for god sake, can "koko" brush up his english before hitting the keyboard
written by richard, November 03, 2009
This government has been wastefully spending billions of our money on perpaduan projects especially at the youth level. Why can't they see that the first roadblock to unity is the biased treatment of bumis into our public universities. Like all fair-minded countries of the world, meritoracy is the rule. If the government wanted the bumis to be on par with the non-bumis, train them from young. If they even cannot fend for themselves even at this level, we, the tax payer will be subsiding them till kingdom come!
written by Observer, November 03, 2009
The government should practise equal opportunity for all irrespective of race or religion in all fields as a fundamental human right.
written by Lautpeluncur, November 03, 2009
This is a sad case, this girl obviously has very good result, yet being denied because of her skin color.

I suggest her to take STPM, it is way better than the matriculation program, STPM has gained world recognition and matriculation has not gained any SOLID recognition even in our own country. With such a good result, I believe she will do very well in STPM and get invited from top universities around the world.

Why eye Malaysia public universities? Eye for top universities around the world.

This will explain why so many public universities graduates can't find a job, and most of them are bumiputera!

Therefore, to this Sarawak girl, instead of seeing it as a sad encounter, I think may be God wants you to take STPM and get into better university. If you see this message, mark my words, strive for STPM, you will land yourself in some good universities around the world with some scholarships. You don't want to enter the matriculation program and enter a university that is lowly regarded and can't find a job when you graduate.
written by Satu Malaysia, November 03, 2009
Here shows how Najib's "Satu Malaysia" is a true lie and can be thrown to sewerage hole!!!
written by dario, November 03, 2009
triple double-u,
With the losing birth rate of Singaporean Chinese compared to other races, Singapore has a risk of having it's Chinese majority outnumbered. So the GIC scholarship is an answer. Serving only 6% Singaporean (Chinese), 2 Malaysian Chinese and the rest of the list are Chinese imported from all over the world. Don't count on shouting "bingo" if you spot a Malay, Indonesian non-Chinese, Indian, Blacks, Mat Sallehs or Jews in this year's list. This is a list that's supposedly for "the bests in the world", which amazingly looks very Chinese. This is from a country that wants their people to think themselves as "Singaporean".

Now, have a drive down Shah Alam to Section 18. There, is THE college for JPA scholars doing prep work for overseas studies. At least for the past 5 years it has been 50% non bumi. Since the beginning of this year, it's occupied by 75% non bumi. Some racist country we are, compared to the beloved your "race-blind" Lee & Sons Pte Ltd down south.
written by Wilson Wong, November 02, 2009
With all due respect James,

I suspect that you really don't like Sarawak. In the past you've managed to ridicule Sarawakians, and frankly I don't think it helps.

If you really want change, then be inclusive! You're helping no one if you keep ostracising them! Do you really expect Sabah and Sarawak to deliver votes to PR if you keep this up? Do you even care about the plight of the people in Borneo? Or do you just want them to deliver votes to PR and then be dispensed of their usefulness?

I'm speaking out of topic here but I feel that it is important to say this.
written by koko, November 02, 2009
There must be a reason why Sarawak people have that rule, could that be that Sarawak native feel that non-bumi will not assimilate with the bumi that they decide to have that rule in place in the constitution? If that is the reason, what the non-bumi waiting? Why not assimilate? Oh.. no, non-bumi will not assimilate, but at the same time you want to take from this Sarawak native their right. If that is the case, why the heck the Sarawak people give you what is their? Its non-brainer issue actually, as long as the non-bumi realise and ACCEPT that they does not live in China or India, which also means not just having an IC, but also speak, live the way of life of the native, etc, etc,.. in effect become bumi, just like Chinese in Thai or Philippines. In there, they are not Chinese anymore, they are Thai or Pinoy. Yeah.. you will not do it, that is why there different school, newspaper, radio station, etc, etc, and at the same time asking for equality...!? My foot!!!
written by Anak Malaysia, November 02, 2009
I think we will educate our young not to study in Malaysia because the Malaysian government is loop-sided and racist. Should we consider Malaysia as South Africa? I think there is a lot of similarities and I was once one of those from my class in Form 3 which I almost kicked out from the 1st class because 38 students in the class are chinese and we all get 5As and above. The so-called Bumiputra student who has less than 3As are placed in our class and a few of us was asked to redelegate to the 2nd class because the max students we can have in the class is 38. Of course we turned rebellion because there is no equality. Why are all the 1st class students are chinese? The reason is plain simple. We are smarter and we know we could not enter local university and we work hard to go overseas to study. We do not want to depend on government scholarships because we are NON-BUMIPUTERA. And this is what we call Malaysia. A country full of racism, double standards, hypocracy & power crazy.

Without the DAP, we can fight for our rights? MCA? No... MCA don't bother about it. If the MCA really look after the chinese, we should get scholarships as easy as the Bumiputera.
written by Sun Quan, November 02, 2009
I think the policy of the BN government is to drive/frustrate all the capable non-malays to emigrate to other countries and force down the rest in the economic ladder and push the malays up to the top echelon of the economy and control the country in all fields. The other races are never to be a threat to the malays especially economically, this is the aim of the present BN government. The rest of the component parties of BN other than UMNO is there to grab whatever they could because they know what UMNO is up to but can't do anything to stop them. Unity among the races is NOT their aim, unity among the malays are their aims. If true Malaysians who love this country and all the people of this country and want a true Malaysian Unity, then they have to unite fast and get rid of the present government and it's most damaging policy and also all those government servants who are bent on pushing the BN policy must be rid off. Time is running out for the true Malaysians and also the other races, the point of no return is approaching fast!
written by shida, November 02, 2009
Good article. Hopefully Malaysia will meet a day of racial free judgment especially in education system. No more "special" learning institution who focus on one race admission. No more sekolah jenis kebangsaan. No more one race base political party. No more Race column in any government or private form!Let's exist as Malaysians and Malaysians only!
written by George Jung, November 02, 2009
James, I'm a bumiputera but to me it doesn't serve me any purpose whether you are one or not because at the end of the day, its how you use the opportunities granted to you that counts. It does not just end whether you're bumi or half or "others", ultimate decider is who signs as proposer. If you don't have political links or if the person that signs on as your proposer is a nobody it comes to nothing also. Its a well known game what these policies are making monkeys of. Just look at the government sector. The policy makers say one thing, the little napoleans make another. Take MAS for example. Can you seriously believe that no other races apply for available posts but only Malays? Those with the political clout can go to whichever Uni they want but look at what they churn out. Half baked graduates who still think that they should be helped instead of helping themselves to the opportunities made available. Bumi my foot..... for as long as the policy stands only for a particular race, you'll have a lot of graduate monkeys loitering around with inflated egos....just for comparison since you're from Sarawak...take a look at the sale of residential houses where its called mixed zone areas...how many of these units are sold to Bumis? This is a good indicator of their purchasing powers. On a level playing ground only a handful will be able to afford these units. If you don't believe go ask around and you'll see what I mean..So to me, bumi or not is irrelevant; cut the skin of either bumi or others and the blood that flows is still red..whats the fuss about???
written by triple double "u" , November 02, 2009
Truely, a sad, sad story. We live in a country that puts race before results and not having foresights of thinking that we need talents like these to develop our nation. Marina's case is only but the tip of the iceberg in race based University drafting that provides seats to undeserving people, just because they are Bumiputras.

With such good results, do what many Malaysian's are doing by applying for a GIS scholarship in Singapore. If you're own country doesn't make you feel wanted, I am sure our neighbours down under will gladly welcome you with open arms. Heck.... they have a population crisis down there
Copyright © 2009 The Malaysian Insider